The Nerfracker #5
Baseball player is sorta bad (5)
We are continuing today our run of Nerfrackers — puzzles with hints for the new solver, and "normal" clues for everyone else. Today's grid is an experiment in having a little more checking involved in the center of the grid to give a few more toeholds.
As with most experiments, we have our hypotheses. Block-style cryptics make new solvers happy because they're the shortest conceptual leap from standard crosswords, and they're favored by many constructors because in order to finish, solvers must crack each clue — nothing gets filled in "accidentally" by crossing letters.
Cryptics that don't have blocks tend to use bars, a la the dearly departed New Yorker cryptics, but this new geography can feel like a slap to new solvers just getting comfortable — though barred grids do often make it possible for answers to get entered using only crossers. (You'll see today's grid permits a few such "accidents.")
So this is an attempt to thread the needle — and give you more clues, too. Let us know if this quixotic attempt to teach fellow Yanks the ropes is "better one? better two?"
We need to also thank our stalwart friend-in-deception joeadultman for his excellent test solve notes. If the clues are have better surfaces, it's because of his diligence. (We also just IRLed Joe for the first time at the inaugural Midwest Gridfest — a good time for many reasons.) For this one, we also checked in with the godfather of indie American cryptics, Steve Mossberg, to make sure that we are keeping these somewhat in line with his quiptics — he's put up a 51st if you haven't checked recently.
Happy to talk pedagogy in the comments.